Using CaringBridge Wellbeing

What People Mean to Say When the Wrong Words Come Out

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone
express support

All of us have either said something we regret, or been on the receiving end of remarks that were supposed to be helpful, but turned out instead to be hurtful.

So why do insensitive and downright dumb things pop out of the mouths of people who truly mean well, especially in response to serious health situations? The short answer: human nature.

Cure for Foot-In-Mouth

In our last article: 7 Things You Should Never Say to Patients or Caregivers, we offered tips on how to keep foot and mouth a fair distance apart.

As a reminder, pinch yourself—really hard—if any of these words ever begin to tumble from your lips:

  •  “Everything happens for a reason.”
  • “This is God’s plan.”
  • “What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.”
  •  “At least it’s not cancer.”
  •  “Just think positive thoughts.”
  • “God doesn’t give you more than you can handle.”
  • “At least you have one healthy child.

Everyone Means Well

And now for a longer answer to the question, “Why Smart People Say Dumb Things?”

People almost always mean well. Most CaringBridge users would probably find this to be true.

But sometimes when people are trying to say they care, or that they feel really bad about what is happening, things get muddy.

If only there was an international signal for “Stop Talking! Right now! Please!”

Translate the Message

It is often helpful to look for the sentiments that lie behind clumsy expressions. What are people actually trying to say when the wrong words come spewing out?

Probably they are trying to say they feel terrible, and would do anything to take away pain and suffering. It’s just not easy to say.

CaringBridge users have said that nearly every mangled communication about a health situation is an attempt to express one or more of the following:

  • “I care.”
  • “You’re so strong.”
  • “I have faith that you’re going to get through this.”
  • “I’m here for you.”
  • “My story that is similar shows I have a glimmer of what you may be going through.”

Care to Share Your Own Tips?

Please add to the conversation by sharing in the “Comment” section below how you may have translated the actual meaning of something that has been poorly said.

Comments (20)

Post a Comment

Rosellen Oct 10, 2017 7:24am
Dear Susan ~ It was great to see you last Tuesday. You are such an important part of my life for the past 44 years! Wishing you strength to overcome both the big challenges and also the not-so-big challenges that pop up along the way. You seem to meet them with great courage and with the spirit you draw from deep within yourself. You are truly an amazing woman!!!
Jane Grudt Oct 05, 2017 9:26pm
I may agree with the "never say" as a caregiver of a spouse in the late stages of Alzheimer's, but it is also damaging to us. You are turning away people that we need to let us know they have not forgotten us. We caregivers are not weak - let us handle those who care enough to show up. I hope my supporters never read any of your writing!
Mavis Sep 16, 2017 3:05pm
thoughtful and helpful article!
June Paul Sep 05, 2017 7:37pm
Upon learning that I had cancer among some other things going on in my life someone told me "It's good for you to suffer." Now, Nobody in even their right mind wants to hear those words. At least that what I thought in the moment and I was hurt. It sounded so uncaring. . . but thinking back, I think the person knew that radiation treatment for cancer is no walk in the park . . . this person had even told me they knew other women who had gone through breast cancer treatment and survived. I think this person meant to say that even though I'm suffering, the treatment will bring a good result. I think - I don't know for sure - but that's what I think - the person who said was in their right mind, I wasn't. I' admit that - I was feeling anxious and nervous. And I remember when a friend of mine told me she had cancer and I said, "I'm sorry you are going through this. Let me know if and how I can help. She said, no - no - no - I don't need you to be sorry for me. I will talk with you some other time, and so all I did was pray and wait until she contacted me again. Different words touch us differently at different times in our lives - and that can put stress on relationships - but Love, Hope and Compassion Are Powerful . . . so is understanding and grace . . . sometimes saying something that might be misunderstood or misinterpreted is better than saying nothing at all . . . at least it shows you care enough to say so . . .
Delores McAllister Sep 02, 2017 7:34pm
Nancie, I am waiting for you to rally! Like you said you have 3 more trips you want to make. I am praying for you and the rest of your family, You can call on me to help in any way. I spoke with Kate and this is the websit.e we are supposed to use to sign up. I can help you tomorrow at 8:30 until 6:00, Also the same for 9/4/2117. Let me knowif this is ok.
Caren Aug 28, 2017 12:40pm
Hello, IN JANUARY 2017 THE LORD PUT IN ON MY HEART TO VISIT A YOUNG WOMAN . I ONLY MET HER 3 TIMES WHEN IS VISITED MY CHURCH .Her Dad was my Bible study teacher at one time ,and we always prayed her. I couldn't possibly imagine the pain that her Mom ,Dad, sister, husband ,daughter 15, son 12 were going through., over the past ten years.I decided to take her a huge pan of hot lasagna, pot full of meatballs ,sauce ,fresh Italian bread, and a chocolate cake. You would have thought it was Christmas . Her face was beaming with joy as she clapped her hands and thanked me over and over. As I sat with her and just talked about her kids and anything funny , I was crying on the inside. It was not only an unexpected surprise for her ,but what an amazing lesson for me. We sometime forget to spread Gods amazing glory in the simplest ways. I continued bringing her meals every other week for the next four months..... Then on April 8th she went home to the lord at forty two. For over ten years Rebecca always praised the lord and worried more about blessing others. What an amazing woman of faith. A few weeks later I continued with the meals.More importantly I was there to hold her daughter in my arms as she cried uncontrollably . I didn't need to say more than " go head let it out. ..... and I love you. ". Showing Gods love is foremost . ..... Blessing to everyone,
Bob Clarke Aug 16, 2017 8:33am
Great advise.
Critter-Girl Aug 12, 2017 1:02pm
Share more articles like this. I'm finding I have to educate everyone around me. The teaching needs to happen BEFORE i get really sick. Most people have not dealt with being really ill. They don't understand the consequences.
Pat Derenburger Aug 11, 2017 10:14am
When I was diagnosed with breast cancer, my "best friend" of 25 years treated me like I had the plague. All she would say was, "I just don't know what to say". As a result, she said less and less until she more or less disappeared from my life. Another friend told me she was praying for me, sent frequent, chatty e-mails, made short, light-hearted calls, and sent cards or notes. That meant the world to me. She found things for us to discuss that weren't connected to my cancer. We found lots of things to laugh about. Getting my mind off my condition and treatment was the best therapy in the world.
Beth Aug 11, 2017 8:04am
Do we HAVE to say something? Just showing up means the world to one who is suffering. A hug, not meaningless words, means more than can be expressed.
Lisamolloy Aug 11, 2017 4:30am
As the mom of my son who amazingly survived three transplants I can only say I remember people's kindness . Of course we will always have people say inappropriate words or phrases, in my experience it was always in good faith. Humor , smiles and hugs help us heal as well.
LuAnne Miller, RN, BSN, PCCN, PHN Aug 10, 2017 11:15pm
Don't ever think that what you say to someone can make them feel better. That's what we all want to do, but you CAN'T make them feel better. Nothing you say will make them feel better. What can help is knowing how much someone cares and maybe to hear them say they are hurting with you. Then the person may not feel so alone.
Gaye Cramp Aug 10, 2017 10:18pm
When I was sick it helped to hear of others who had come through it and were healthy again.
Donna Blauw Aug 10, 2017 10:07pm
One thing that just came to mind was; is there anything you need help wit, laundry, house cleaning, or anything you can think of let me know.
Betty M Brown Aug 10, 2017 10:00pm
Appropriate comments--might help take the hurt away from inappropriate comments that well-intentioned folks use. Hope so.
Sylvia Goldman Aug 10, 2017 9:23pm
Thank you SO much for putting this out there, CaringBridge! I think the best thing that someone can do sometimes in a situation when they're with a person who is very ill is to either say, "I'm so sorry" or don't say anything at all & just give them a hug or hold their hand. People maybe mean well when they say some of these comments, but if they would just stop & think before they speak about what they sound like, perhaps they won't say it!
Nancy Miller Aug 10, 2017 8:28pm
When my son died, I used a shortcut for "Forgive the stupid people,". FTSP!! All my friends and family knew the signal for when someone was trying to help, but said the most inane things to someone experiencing extreme grief. It made us laugh and lightened our hearts, while forgiving their mistakes.
Priscilla Peterson Aug 10, 2017 8:08pm
My mother died after a 14-year struggle with Alzheimer's. Most of that time I was the family member in charge of her care, and when she died I had such a mix of emotions: I had come to feel as though she was another one of my own "children" that I was taking care of, and as though I had let her down; I missed her terribly, not just because she was my mother but because we had been professional colleagues and true friends. Amazingly, someone actually said to me after she died, "You must be so relieved"! I wasn't at all sure how to take that (relieved because she died? because I didn't have to take care of her anymore?), but I chose to hope that the person meant "relieved that she is no longer suffering." When a person dies who has been ill for a long time, never assume you know what the family or caregivers are feeling!
kay newberry Aug 10, 2017 7:44pm
Great tips for what to say or not say.
JO BRAY Aug 10, 2017 7:41pm
After having lost 4 close family members in the last few years I would suggest that telling someone that they are strong isn't the best thing to say to someone. That is an assumption that may or may not be true and telling a person what you hope they are isn't very helpful. I suggest that be taken off the list. A simple "I'm sorry " or 'I'm sorry for your lost" is a very good, simple thing to say. It also takes in a lot of considerations such as how long ago did this happen, how.close you are to the person and also where you are where and how many people are around. I believe letting the survivor lead the direction of the conversation is very understanding and kind. If you think of something to say and you wonder if its appropriate, it probably isn't. Just being there can bring sa lot of comfort.